Dominance of the benthic flux of rare earth elements on continental shelves

The rare earth elements (REEs) are widely used to track biogeochemical processes in the oceans. Nevertheless, source-to-sink processes for oceanic REEs remain poorly understood, leading to controversial hypotheses proposed to explain oceanic REE distributions: the top-down versus the bottom-up control. In particular, recent modelling efforts suggest that remobilization of continental margin sediments can be a major source of oceanic REEs. However, the sediment pore water REE data, which provide the direct evidence for a benthic dissolved flux, are still scarce.

Deng and his colleagues (2022, reference below) focus on one of the largest land–ocean interfaces in Asia, the Changjiang (Yangtze) River–East China Sea system. Sediment pore water REE data show that release of REEs, from shallow pore water to overlying seawater, is coupled to Mn reduction. In contrast, REEs are removed in deep pore water, perhaps via formation of an authigenic REE-bearing phase. Further calculations suggest that the advection-based benthic flux is the largest Nd source (~40 %) on the East China Sea shelf. Globally, however, despite a higher benthic Nd flux on the advection-dominated shelf, the much more extensive deep ocean may still dominate the total area-integrated benthic flux. These results highlight the need for precise constraints on the benthic source if REE/Nd isotopes are to be robustly used as process/source tracer in both marginal seas and on global scales.

Figure 1: Sampling stations in the Changjiang Estuary–East China Sea (ECS) shelf transect. Major water masses in the study area in summer are indicated: CDW – Changjiang Diluted Water, ECSCC – East China Sea Coastal Current, TWC – Taiwan Warm Current, and KSSW – Kuroshio Surface/Subsurface Water.
Figure 2: Schematic plot of REE cycling on the East China Sea shelf. The colour (light-dark blue) indicates the dissolved REE concentration in pore water or estuarine water. It suggests that release of REEs from shallow pore water to overlying seawater is coupled to Mn reduction. In contrast, REEs are removed in deep pore water, perhaps via formation of an authigenic REE-bearing phase. This sedimentary source could potentially explain REE addition in the estuary at mid-high salinity, in contrast to REE removal by scavenging at low salinity.


Deng, K., Yang, S., Du, J., Lian, E., & Vance, D. (2022). Dominance of benthic flux of REEs on continental shelves: implications for oceanic budgets. Geochemical Perspectives Letters, 22, 26–30. Access the paper: 10.7185/geochemlet.2223

Latest highlights

Overlooked riverine contributions of dissolved neodymium and hafnium to the Amazon estuary and oceans

Xu and colleagues investigated the isotopic composition of dissolved neodymium and hafnium along the entire salinity gradient of the Amazon estuary.

Pulling back the veil on reversible scavenging of lead

This work further contains the role that reversible scavenging may play in the cycling of lead in the ocean, an ever-evolving global experiment where lead contamination can be tracked in real-time.

Extremely high radioactive levels in the manganese nodules

Volz and co-authors demonstrate that radioisotopes in the manganese nodules mostly exceed exempt activity levels…

The North Pacific Ocean, a key actor for the zinc oceanic cycle

Sieber and his colleagues lift the veil on some of the mechanisms that control the behavior of zinc in the Pacific Ocean, and more globally.